Tuesday, June 23, 2009

Learning is a beach

I was doing some work for a client in Florida during my family’s annual sojourn to the beach so the timing was perfect to combine work with pleasure. I spent many hours working but found some time to enjoy sand and surf with my kids, building sand castles and boogie boarding. While waiting for that “perfect wave” I had a thought about how training organizations function.

Boogie boarding is not hard which is why I do it. It’s a fun activity for my kids and I to share that doesn’t require too much fancy equipment. I find myself constantly telling them to wait for the “right” wave and to be patient. Here lies the connection to training.

Often training professionals spend too much time waiting for the perfect moment to unleash their solutions on the organization. We bog down in “economic times”, “operations initiatives”, and “strategic focus” and don’t act when we know that we have solid solutions that would improve the organization. We find ourselves trapped because training is considered an add-on to the day-to-day events.

By shifting from training to learning, the learning organization can release its solutions and all members can avail themselves of the knowledge as needed. Of course, this only happens when the training department has built credibility and the business respects the output of the training department. In other words:

1. The training department has to be
clued in to the business.
2. The solutions created have proven to have impact on results.
3. The training department has to have a seat at the operations table.

By incorporating more on demand solutions in the form of performance support tools, job aids, and
social media, learners utilize learning tools when they need it, rather than when it’s convenient to roll them out.

At the same time, there is something to be said for “striking when the iron is hot.” Just like waiting for the perfect wave, sometimes the training department needs to be patient and wait for that perfect opportunity to launch a learning tool or program. When the conditions are right, that kind of launch will allow for a cool ride rather than a short spurt that doesn’t provide that needed rush of enthusiasm.

The demand for training often emulates the ebb and flow of the tide. If we just relax and watch for the right moment, we can catch that perfect wave and ride it into quality learning. At the same time, like a ship at sea, we have to adjust to the motion and make the best use of the resources at hand to keep the ship and crew on course.

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Virtual Leadership

A bit of a personal note to start. Recently I was hired to do some project work for a colleague I knew from a previous organization. As I am new to independent consulting, this is my first "job" and I am very excited about the opportunity. My client is several states away and I am working more independently than ever. It got me thinking about the virtual work force and how management has to be different.

In today's increasingly virtual world, the remote worker is becoming the norm. The only reason to have people in offices is to appeal to our conventional sense of workplace community. For many people, the face-to-face is the best part of the job. There are plenty of times I wish I could lean over the wall to my buddy and bounce ideas around. My dogs are great listeners, but they aren't too quick with ideas.

Managers need to be taught how to manage a virtual workforce. The foundations of management: motivation, feedback, coaching, direction, setting expectations, follow-up, all still apply to the remote worker. The expectations of how work is accounted for is the difference. Managers need to change the way they look at how work gets done. The remote employee can't be managed by the time clock; instead they have to be managed by the work. There needs to be clear communication between supervisors and employees about how much work needs to be done and can be done. Feedback has to be more frequent and there needs to be trust and open dialogue. Managers need to push the limits and make sure employees are working at high capacity. If the work isn't getting done, then tough conversations need to take place.

Employees also need to be taught how to succeed in this arena. We'd all love to work from home in our pajamas, but that's not the reality. The benefit of being home to take the kids to school and help with the school play has to fit between the work or the trust is broken. Remote employees need to learn the art of self-management and personal accountability. I admit that instead of coffee breaks, I take laundry breaks. I enjoy the freedom of being able to take my kids to school and pick them up. At the same time, I put in very productive work hours between 8 pm and 11 pm when my house is relatively quiet. I also over communicate to my client and ask for feedback often to make sure that I am on track and meeting expectations.

Learning organizations can't continue to just teach management and leadership for the conventional office. Management programs need to address the fundamentals and then explore how they really happen on the shop floor, in the restaurant kitchen, between the cubicles and over the Internet. I propose that well designed management training mirrors the way management should operate. The design should be blended to include online learning, web enabled discussions, face-to-face time and communication by phone and email. Employees also need to be developed to work effectively and be encouraged to challenge themselves to continuously earn the benefit of working remotely.

A more virtual workforce can be a great thing for the environment, for families and for productivity. As usual, high performing organizations get that way by having a strong sense of purpose, solid values and managers that excel at shaping and guiding the organization. Learning professionals would be wise to embrace the trend and help leaders and workers adapt to the new age.

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

If you don't measure it, it doesn't matter

Josh Bersin recently reported some frightening numbers on the state of learning. It reminded me of something we made central to our leadership training in my last position: if you don't measure it, it doesn't matter. This became foundational to our management and leadership training and we encouraged managers to examine their own behavior. Managers soon discovered that their behavior and what they recognized drove the behavior of their team members.

The same is true of learning organizations. The courses and programs that get the most attention or are favored by the leadership team get grandfathered in (to use Bersin's phrase) or overlooked when programs are being cut. The real value lies in the data. As my old boss used to emphasize, "Make data driven decisions." Proper analysis goes a long way to making the case to keep programs or cut them and will help win the war at the budget table. More than simple level one or two analysis, quality program evaluation drives level three and four feedback (Kirkpatrick's model that we all know and love) and secures a place for the training department at the table in driving organizational performance.

Unfortunately, few organizations, under ten percent, are performing that level of measurement. Today's training department barely has the bandwidth to produce training to keep pace with demand. Detailed evaluation puts a strain on the available resources. Doing the analysis to make data driven decision about the existing curriculum seems too backward thinking and no one wants to look back. I would also bet that few organizations have systems that facilitate the gathering, analysis, and storage of the information required.

Measurement doesn't have to be a high tech solution, although there are some very good high tech solutions out there. Class surveys can be very effective, when well written, and can be delivered electronically or via pen and paper. Data entry is cheap in the short term. After the training, make sure to follow-up and gather data on job performance related to training impact. This is measured from participants and their peers, managers, and employees. Getting 360 data, 60 to 90 days after training, is invaluable in determining training effectiveness. Keep it up, make it a habit. You can continue to pay for labor to do data entry if necessary. Take the local Excel expert to lunch in exchange for doing some impromptu analysis. Eventually, the number of responses and the insights gained from the data will demand a high tech solution for data gathering and data mining.

When we coached managers about being careful what you measure, we often used the example of the lack of consistency among managers in the restaurant. Team members quickly learn about a manager's pet peeves, the things he or she measures, and they work very hard to avoid those things. This doesn't mean that the restaurant is achieving the organizational goals of creating great guest experiences, increasing sales, being safe or controlling costs. But it was doing a great job of avoiding punishment.

Be careful what you measure. When you measure learning and practice some effective culling, you end up with a stronger learning library and a highly productive set of tools. When you only measure participant reaction, or worse, measure the wrong behavior as part of your level three analysis, you will end up diminishing the reputation of your training department. Don't just try to avoid punishment. Design the training with the end in mind, i.e., impact on performance. Then look for ways to show how training is helping the organization achieve its goals.

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

Making Leaders

They say that leaders are born not made. I don't know who "they" are but I disagree and so do others including Colin Powell.

Think about the best boss you ever had. I'll bet he/she had years of experience. I'll bet he/she had plenty of stories of successes and failures that shaped managerial behavior. I'll bet he/she empowered you to make decisions, recognized your hard work, provided feedback and coaching and rewarded results. In other words, these leaders were made, not born. They had learned how to translate the vision of the organization into actionable practices. They learned how to communicate their own vision of excellence and how to model it and reinforce the behavior that supported it.

What does all this mean for the learning organization? Learning and organizational development go hand in hand. To develop future leaders, organizations utilize sound succession planning strategies and encourage development plans and professional growth. This works well for the high potential employees who have been selected as future leaders. To truly grow leadership, I would argue that you need to cast the net a bit wider.

1. Teach the fundamentals across the organization. There are a core set of communication and feedback skills that everyone should know. These skills should be used every day between managers and employees and between peers. The skills are the basis for every other leadership paradigm. For example, Situational Leadership is a very popular coaching model (you can learn more about the model at wikipedia.org or through a very well put together online course). I am a huge fan of Situational Leadership, but asking someone to diagnose and then engage in the correct leadership style is still a tough task. They can probably make the right choice but do they have the skills required to handle the conversation and respond appropriately. When everyone in the organization has the skills, they are more likely to hold everyone accountable to the behavior.

2. Continuing Leadership education. It is not enough to roll out the yearly management skills course, or hold biannual leadership conferences. These are great tools and go a long way to maintaining a consistent leadership environment. I would also add informal learning to the mix. Provide opportunities for leaders to share success and failure and learn from each other. Some of my most successful classes involved sharing the "war stories" and allowing leaders time to learn from each other. Consider creating easy to implement tools that leaders can take back to their work groups to continue leadership education on their own and gather feedback. There is plenty being written about leadership in books, articles, white papers, web seminars and other places. Create a clearinghouse through which your leaders can easily access these resources and enjoy them as needed.

3. Create a culture in which feedback is a good thing. Some people love feedback. They see it as an opportunity to improve and receive recognition for their effort. Many people fear feedback and with good reason. I've seen (and received) feedback delivered poorly and it does very little to improve performance. Teaching people how to give and receive feedback goes back to my first point. Once the foundation is in place, create opportunities for people to receive feedback on a regular basis.

4. Create vertical alignment. Leadership starts at the top of an organization. If the senior leadership isn't bought in to leadership development, no amount of training intervention is going to matter because the senior leadership doesn't recognize it or reward it. Fortunately, this isn't the case in most organizations. Keep the top of the organization in tune with the leadership training by offering them a place in the program as a speaker, facilitator, or participant. Offer them access to the same informal opportunities to leadership content.


Leadership is a hot topic these days. Plenty is being written and there is always room to improve it and drive performance. Make sure that in your organization leadership is something everyone is involved in, not just a select few.

Sunday, April 12, 2009

Leading, Learning and Change

Everywhere you look, learning professionals and consultants are writing about coping with tough times, surviving the downturn, or bracing for the worst. I don't blame them, times are tough and many people I talk to are cutting corners and balancing expenses. By people I mean friends, family, and business contacts. Personally or professionally, anyone with a checkbook is paying even closer attention to what's going out.


So when I ask training leaders, and I've spoken to quite a few, what the biggest learning need is in these times, I get a handful of answers: leadership, continuing development, and change management top the charts. I think these are very achievable and can be closely aligned with your business results.


1. Leadership Training. Spend the time developing leaders to be more successful and building your succession plan. And face it, they will leave. Strong leaders will help guide your company in these challenging times and then be tempted away when conditions improve. How you keep them is a different conversation, but make sure you have their successor lined up.

The other benefit to leadership development is the establishment of a shared language. Leadership development, done right, involves both the leaders and the led. It creates a common understanding of the role of leaders and accountability for leadership behaviors. Employees know what to expect from their leaders, managers are better able to provide peer coaching and feedback, and executive leadership has an "apples to apples" way of describing and identifying high performers in the organization. For more on leadership and succession planning, Talent Management has a very good article on developing emerging leaders.

2. Continuing Development. Many organization are adopting the "do more with less" mentality these days. I don't have a problem with that, as long as people are prepared to do the work you need them to do, and that might mean more training. Yet in the "more with less" mindset, the learning organization has less to work with. Once again, social media comes to the rescue as does a proactive communication plan.

  • Let the organization know you are creating informal learning and development opportunities.

  • Communicate the topic areas and the means to obtain training.

  • Partner those who have skills with those who don't for more peer training and informal development.

  • Have experts answer questions on discussion boards or document success in wikis.

  • Create lunch and learn sessions through which experts can share experience and answer questions.

  • Remind employees to document learning opportunities and time spent practicing new skills.

  • Remind your experts to document time spent teaching, training or mentoring. Ask them how you can help develop them further by making them better trainers.

This continuing development should fit hand-in-hand with your leadership development and succession planning process.

3. Teach people how to manage change. Change management isn't just a task for the senior leadership or the training department. Managing how team members cope with and respond to changing conditions falls to front line leaders. Since these line managers may be formal or informal leaders, it is important to create an awareness in the population of how people handle change and how to help people use the tension to move forward and be productive. I'm not arguing for enterprise-wide change management training. I am arguing for creating opportunities for the entire workforce to learn about the change process and some of the ways that successful organizations handle and grow from change pressure.

To be successful, organizations need to continually grow, develop and innovate. By focusing on a leadership platform, all team members share accountability for leadership. Through continuing development, team members have an opportunity to grow and be successful. Continuing development doesn't have to draw on excessive resources when information sharing becomes the norm. Finally, create a culture that knows how to adapt to and use the tension caused by change events and you will have an organization ready to cope with the challenges of today and tomorrow.

Tuesday, April 7, 2009

Training with the Experience in Mind

While perusing the blogs I follow, I reacquainted myself with this article from Josh Bersin. I was pleased to see that my ideas align pretty well and I was able to learn a few new things. I love the focus on informal, casual learning and the value of networks. I've been blogging about informal learning quite a bit and was pleased to see I'm on track.

I also enjoyed some of the specifics regarding human networks outlined in this recent article in CLO magazine. It got me thinking about the power of people and the kind of experience they have getting the information they need in a practical, timely fashion. User experience always brings me back to the work of Lou Carbone and his book Clued In: How to Keep Customers Coming Back Again and Again. This book really changed the way I viewed the guest experience and as such changed the way I think about developing learning tools.

1. Develop tools with the end user in mind. Specifically, what is the emotional connection you want users to make with the tools or learning experience? Developing learning interventions can become fairly methodical. Great learning professionals also consider the overall experience of the user and strive to measure the degree to which participants feel confident, secure, knowledgeable and prepared.

2. Develop tools with the customer in mind. Your clients eventually interact with your organization's clients. How would those individuals describe your people? The tools prepare learners to perform on the job, but are they performing in a way that creates an enjoyable experience for the guest and a profitable experience for the organization? For example, sales teams are provided plenty of material on "up-selling" or "adding value." I would ask how the guest perceives the outcomes of the training. Do they feel like they are getting a better service experience or do they feel are they being pushed to purchase things they don't want.

3. Keep it simple. Make learning tools easy to obtain, easy to use, easy to reuse, easy to share. The Bersin article calls it "Facilitating Learning." Learning organizations have plenty of informal tools and can guide and enable learning rather than focus on delivering training.

To come full circle, I think high-impact learning organizations also make the learner experience an important part of their design process. More than just a look at the user requirements, training solutions should be built within the context of the entire learning structure and organization's cultural experience.

Friday, April 3, 2009

Ben Franklin Would Tell You To Go With The Blended Solution

"Moderation in all things -- including moderation." - Benjamin Franklin

Lately I have been in several friendly debates with high school teachers over the use of Second Life in secondary education. There seems to be some hesitation in some quarters about losing face time with students. Great teachers have learned to measure the effectiveness of their training session by a glance around the room. They value that face-to-face contact.

On the other hand, many companies and universities are taking their training more and more virtual. Second Life and webinar tools have become viable options for conducting group sessions. Presenters can deliver content, manage breakout groups, have groups report findings, create flip charts...all the tools of the classroom. Voice over IP has even enabled users to hear each other rather than spend the time in text chat.

Some argue that virtual worlds and social networking are the next progression of our social evolution (check out this article from the New York Times, online). In many ways, social networks are logical extensions of our tribal culture: we share ideas, we trade virtual trinkets, we form groups based on common interests and goals.

But what about human interaction? Aren't we social animals with a need for face time, to see a person's expression and react? I would argue that all this virtual time makes actual face-to-face time that much more valuable to learning. Great learning solutions can be built that engage people on both levels.

1. Create engaging online experiences. Use Second Life, webinars, or online resources to create virtual tools and resources that learners want to reuse. Let those experiences create excitement, interest, and healthy tension.

2. Teach people how to facilitate discussions. Once the online piece is complete, have people meet to discuss the content presented. They will all be part of the group called "People who experienced online content." They will have a shared history and experience to get them started and will begin to collaborate and build group norms. Train leaders to facilitate group discussion and draw out ideas and action plans. Encourage learners to form these groups in their work place rather than online to build social interaction and support networks.

3. Use virtual space for continuing development and follow-up. Once a group has formed in real space, encourage them to extend their influence into virtual space through online meetings, wikis, blogs, and discussion boards. By working through the first steps, groups may "unlock" (to use a gaming term) additional content and resources.

Classroom learning is becoming too costly to remain the predominant delivery tool of corporate training. Online delivery is becoming less expensive, easier to produce and sometimes, in the case of Second Life, as good as classroom learning. Human interaction is still an integral part of learning for many people and shouldn't be eliminated entirely. The best options usually combine the flavor and benefits of multiple delivery vehicles.